The Talent Gap Starts in the Classroom
Supply chain employers keep asking for graduates who can think end-to-end, manage trade-offs, and collaborate under pressure. Here is how one university is actually delivering that and what it means for the profession.
Every year, supply chain organizations hire new graduates who know what a bullwhip effect is but have never felt the pressure of deciding whether to dual-source a critical component when a supplier goes dark. They can define safety stock but freeze when demand spikes 30 percent and production capacity is already maxed out. They understand S&OP in theory but have never sat in a room where sales, operations, and finance are pulling in three different directions and someone must make a call.
This is not a criticism of graduates. It is a structural problem with how supply chain has traditionally been taught.
At the Neeley School of Business at Texas Christian University, we spent years recognizing this gap in our own classrooms before deciding to do something about it. What follows is what we learned and why we believe it matters for the profession as a whole.
“They can define safety stock but freeze when demand spikes 30 percent and production capacity is already maxed out.”
Why Traditional Instruction Alone is Not Enough
Supply chain is, at its core, an integrative discipline. Finance, operations, logistics, procurement, and commercial functions do not succeed in isolation they succeed when they move together. Yet most university curricula teach these functions in separate courses, with separate professors, graded on separate exams. Students graduate having studied the parts but never assembled the whole.
The consequences show up immediately on the job. New hires often understand their functional role but struggle to anticipate how their decisions travel downstream. They optimize locally when the situation demands systemic thinking. They communicate in functional language when cross-functional alignment is what’s needed.
Compounding this is the problem of abstraction. Classical supply chain models — EOQ, newsvendor, safety stock formulas — are mathematically elegant but increasingly disconnected from the digital, demand-volatile, globally disrupted supply chains that graduates will actually manage. Students sense the mismatch. Engagement drops. The concepts are memorized for exams and forgotten within weeks.
We know this because we watched it happen in our own classrooms, for years, before we decided to find a more effective means of teaching the complexity and collaborative need in Supply Chains. Pivoting to experimental learning does not take away the learning of classical supply chain models but rather provide relative context to apply them.
Experiential Learning: What It Actually Means
Experiential learning is not a field trip or a guest speaker. It is a deliberate pedagogical design rooted in a simple premise: people learn by doing, reflecting, and doing again — not by listening and memorizing. David Kolb’s foundational research on experiential learning makes this case rigorously, and decades of subsequent research on business simulation confirms it: students who learn through doing retain more, transfer knowledge more effectively, and develop stronger professional judgment than those taught through traditional instruction alone.
What this means in practice is a course built around The Fresh Connection, a sophisticated end-to-end supply chain simulation used by leading universities and corporate training programs globally. Students assume executive roles — VP of Sales, VP of Purchasing, VP of Operations, VP of Supply Chain — inside a simulated juice manufacturing company. Every round, they set strategies, negotiate constraints, and make interdependent decisions with real consequences for company ROI.
Unlike simulations that focus on a single functional discipline, The Fresh Connection requires students to simultaneously balance financial performance, customer service, operational efficiency, supplier relationships, sustainability, and organizational alignment. Success rarely comes from optimizing one variable—it comes from managing competing priorities across the enterprise.
The learning that follows is qualitatively different from classroom learning. Students do not just know that inventory decisions affect service levels — they have watched their own inventory decision crater their team’s fill rate in round two and spent round three figuring out how to recover. That is the kind of knowledge that travels with them into careers.
“Students do not just know that inventory decisions affect service levels — they have watched their own inventory decision crater their fill rate and spent the next round figuring out how to recover.”
Students often gain their greatest insights not from achieving the highest financial performance, but from the consequences of poor decisions. Supply chain leaders operate under uncertainty, where even well-reasoned decisions may not always produce the desired outcome. Our student team debriefs focus less on whether a team “won” or “lost” and more on the quality of their decision-making process—the data they used, the assumptions they made, the trade-offs they considered, and the reasoning behind their choices. As experienced business leaders know, we often learn as much—or more—from our failures than from our successes.
Over multiple semesters, we’ve consistently observed that the richest classroom discussions occur not after teams achieve the highest ROI, but after they experience unexpected setbacks and work collaboratively to understand what happened, challenge their assumptions, and determine how they would approach the situation differently the next time.
For employers, this means graduates who are not afraid to make difficult decisions, who can critically evaluate the outcomes of those decisions, and who continuously improve rather than repeating the same mistakes. They enter the workforce with greater resilience, stronger business judgment, and a mindset of continuous learning—qualities that are difficult to develop through traditional lecture-based instruction alone.
Traditional lecture-based instruction can effectively teach concepts, but it cannot fully replicate the accountability that comes from owning a decision and experiencing its consequences. In the simulation, students are not analyzing someone else’s case—they are evaluating the results of their own decisions, defending their reasoning, and adapting their strategy based on those outcomes. That combination of ownership, reflection, and adaptation develops managerial judgment in ways that lectures and textbooks simply cannot.
Changing How We Teach Is Not Without Resistance
Transforming the classroom has not been without challenges, and we would be doing our colleagues a disservice to suggest otherwise. Within academia, moving away from traditional lectures, textbooks, and examinations can encounter resistance from faculty who are understandably comfortable with established teaching methods and skeptical of approaches that require fundamentally different course design and assessment. Students can be equally resistant. Many have spent years succeeding in educational environments where expectations are clearly defined, answers are readily available, and success is measured by reproducing what they have been taught. When suddenly confronted with ambiguous problems, competing priorities, and the responsibility to defend their own decisions, some embrace the challenge while others push back—sometimes quite forcefully. Critical thinking is uncomfortable, particularly when there is no single correct answer and mistakes have visible consequences. We have learned that this discomfort is not necessarily evidence that the approach is failing; it can be an important part of the learning process. Our responsibility as educators is not to eliminate that discomfort, but to provide the structure, coaching, and accountability that help students work through it. Meaningful educational transformation requires a willingness from both faculty and students to move beyond what is familiar.
The Skills Employers Actually Need — and How Experiential Learning Builds Them
When supply chain employers describe what recent graduates lack, the list is remarkably consistent: systemic thinking, the ability to make decisions under uncertainty, cross-functional communication, and the judgment to navigate trade-offs when there is no clean answer. These are not soft skills. They are core professional competencies — and they cannot be developed in a lecture hall.
Simulation builds them because it forces students to live inside the trade-offs. Consider what a student playing VP of Sales must actually do: negotiate customer service levels that are commercially attractive without promising more than operations can deliver, manage shelf-life constraints that punish excess inventory, and align with a VP of Supply Chain who has a completely different view of acceptable risk. That negotiation — repeated across multiple rounds, with consequences — is more valuable than any case study about it.
Unlike textbook problems that present complete information and a correct answer, real supply chain decisions are made with incomplete information, competing objectives, and uncertain outcomes. The simulation intentionally recreates that environment, allowing students to develop judgment under conditions that closely resemble professional practice.
We also address team dynamics directly as team composition matters as much as team effort. Student teams complete a Belbin Team Roles assessment, a validated behavioral model that identifies nine roles people naturally play in groups. A group of four brilliant strategists with no one willing to coordinate logistics or hold the team accountable to deadlines will underperform a team with complementary strengths and most students have never been asked to think about their own teams that way. The Belbin framework gives them language for it: roles like Shaper, Implementer, and Completer-Finisher describe behavioral tendencies, not job titles, and naming them turns a vague sense that “our team struggles to get things done” into a specific, addressable gap.
AI analysis of the results delivers personalized team feedback inside the simulation — identifying gaps in role coverage, surfacing mismatches between how individuals see themselves and how their teammates see them, and prompting the kind of honest team conversation that most students have never had in an academic setting. The value shows up in how teams actually use the results. When the AI-generated feedback flags that a team is heavy on ideas-generators and light on implementers, students don’t just read that observation they have to decide how to compensate for it before the next round, whether that means one person deliberately stepping into an unfamiliar role or the team building in an extra check on follow-through. That is a rehearsal for something every one of them will face on the job: joining a cross-functional team they didn’t choose, staffed with people whose working styles don’t naturally match their own, and needing to make it function anyway.
We also hear this reflected in our students’ internship and job interviews. Students frequently return excited that what began as a traditional question-and-answer interview evolved into an engaging discussion about their simulation experience, the decisions their team faced, the trade-offs they navigated, the setbacks they overcame, and the lessons they learned. Students frequently tell us that interviewers remark they wish they had a similar simulation environment within their own organizations to help develop managers and strengthen cross-functional decision-making. Those conversations reinforce our belief that experiential learning not only prepares students for the workplace but also gives them meaningful experiences to discuss with prospective employers that distinguish them from other candidates.
AI as a Decision Coach, Not a Decision Maker, Generative AI is reshaping business education as fast as it is reshaping business. The profession’s concern is legitimate: if students can use AI to complete any written assignment, what are they actually learning? Our experience suggests that experiential, simulation-based design is one of the most robust responses to this challenge — and that AI, used correctly, can deepen learning rather than undermine it.
After each simulation round, students receive AI-generated dynamic debriefs: personalized coaching messages grounded in that team’s actual decisions and performance data. The AI does not provide answers. It asks questions. Why did your service level drop in round three even though you increased safety stock? What was the downstream effect of the sourcing decision your purchasing VP made in round two? What would you change?
This is AI functioning as a pedagogical coach — scaling the kind of individualized feedback that a professor with sixty students cannot personally provide. And because assessment questions are grounded in each team’s specific simulation history, generic AI-generated responses are useless. A student cannot ask ChatGPT to write their reflection on a decision their team never made. The design is its own integrity mechanism.
The distinction we draw for students — and that the profession would benefit from drawing more broadly — is between AI as a replacement for thinking and AI as an accelerant for thinking. The former produces graduates who are dependent and brittle. The latter produces graduates who are adaptable and dangerous in the best sense of the word.
What the Profession Can Do
The skills gap between academic supply chain training and industry requirements is real, persistent, and well-documented. Closing it requires more than curriculum reform at individual institutions. It requires the profession to engage more actively with how the next generation is being prepared.
That means supply chain organizations being specific with university partners about the competencies they value most — not just “critical thinking” in the abstract, but the ability to run an S&OP process, to manage a supplier relationship under constraint, to make a data-driven inventory decision and explain the reasoning to a commercial team. It means creating internship and co-op structures that extend experiential learning beyond the classroom. And it means recognizing that the institutions taking pedagogical risks — scrapping textbooks, building simulation-based curricula, integrating AI as a coaching tool — deserve industry partnership, not just polite appreciation. The students coming out of programs like this are not the ones who memorized the most. They are the ones who made the most mistakes in a safe environment, reflected on what went wrong, and learned to do better. Those are the professionals supply chains need right now.
The gap is closeable. But it closes faster when industry and academia are working on it together. The supply chain profession does not need graduates who simply know more. It needs graduates who can think systemically, make sound decisions under uncertainty, collaborate across functions, and continuously improve when those decisions do not produce the expected outcome. Developing these capabilities is not simply an educational challenge—it is a competitive imperative for the future of the profession.
Final Thoughts from the Authors
Ultimately, the success of experiential education should not be measured solely by student satisfaction or simulation performance. A team achieving a high return on investment does not necessarily demonstrate that every member has developed strong business judgment. We are increasingly focused on whether students can explain the reasoning behind their decisions, recognize unintended consequences, articulate cross-functional trade-offs, and apply lessons from one situation to another. These are more demanding measures of learning, but they are also far closer to the capabilities employers expect from graduates entering the profession.
Written by: Patti Jordan, Professor of Professional Practice Supply Chain
Laura Meade, Professor of Professional Practice Supply Chain
Mark Layton, Sr. Instructor – Supply Chain
More Blogs
Think Small to Win Big: Rethinking Supply Chain Design in the Age of E-Commerce